About Us

Founded in 1973 by Moshe Fialkoff and his family, Fialkoff’s Kosher Pizza began in Monticello, NY with a single mission: to bring authentic, flavorful kosher pizza to the American Midwest. Their unwavering commitment to quality and tradition set a new standard for pizza in the region, quickly making the brand a beloved staple for camps, bungalow gatherings, and everyday family meals. From the very first loaf, the family’s passion for culinary excellence has resonated across generations, earning the company a reputation for both taste and integrity.
Every slice starts with hand-tossed dough crafted from locally sourced grains, then layered with a tomato sauce simmered with fresh herbs and a generous blend of mozzarella, provolone, and a touch of sharp cheddar. The result is a perfectly balanced flavor profile that satisfies both the heart and the soul. Fialkoff’s commitment to using only certified kosher ingredients ensures that every bite is safe, wholesome, and true to tradition.
As the years rolled on, Fialkoff’s grew from a single pizzeria into a community icon, celebrated for its crispy crusts, inventive toppings, and the warm, inviting atmosphere that invites patrons to share memorable moments. Whether it’s a weekend campfire gathering or a quiet family dinner, the aroma of fresh pizza draws people in, creating an atmosphere of togetherness that has kept the brand thriving for almost five decades.
Today, the flagship location at 250 E Broadway in Monticello remains the heart of the operation, yet Fialkoff’s has expanded to serve customers across New York, New Jersey, and Florida. With convenient online ordering, free delivery options, and a dedicated catering service, you can experience the same outstanding flavor from the comfort of your own home or at any special event. Discover why Fialkoff’s is the go-to choice for kosher pizza lovers everywhere. Phone: 973-533-1424